Fallback mechanisms

A fallback mechanism is supported to allow to overcome failures to do a direct filesystem lookup on the root filesystem or when the firmware simply cannot be installed for practical reasons on the root filesystem. The kernel configuration options related to supporting the firmware fallback mechanism are:

  • CONFIG_FW_LOADER_USER_HELPER: enables building the firmware fallback mechanism. Most distributions enable this option today. If enabled but CONFIG_FW_LOADER_USER_HELPER_FALLBACK is disabled, only the custom fallback mechanism is available and for the request_firmware_nowait() call.
  • CONFIG_FW_LOADER_USER_HELPER_FALLBACK: force enables each request to enable the kobject uevent fallback mechanism on all firmware API calls except request_firmware_direct(). Most distributions disable this option today. The call request_firmware_nowait() allows for one alternative fallback mechanism: if this kconfig option is enabled and your second argument to request_firmware_nowait(), uevent, is set to false you are informing the kernel that you have a custom fallback mechanism and it will manually load the firmware. Read below for more details.

Note that this means when having this configuration:

CONFIG_FW_LOADER_USER_HELPER=y CONFIG_FW_LOADER_USER_HELPER_FALLBACK=n

the kobject uevent fallback mechanism will never take effect even for request_firmware_nowait() when uevent is set to true.

Justifying the firmware fallback mechanism

Direct filesystem lookups may fail for a variety of reasons. Known reasons for this are worth itemizing and documenting as it justifies the need for the fallback mechanism:

  • Race against access with the root filesystem upon bootup.
  • Races upon resume from suspend. This is resolved by the firmware cache, but the firmware cache is only supported if you use uevents, and its not supported for request_firmware_into_buf().
  • Firmware is not accessible through typical means:
    • It cannot be installed into the root filesystem
    • The firmware provides very unique device specific data tailored for the unit gathered with local information. An example is calibration data for WiFi chipsets for mobile devices. This calibration data is not common to all units, but tailored per unit. Such information may be installed on a separate flash partition other than where the root filesystem is provided.

Types of fallback mechanisms

There are really two fallback mechanisms available using one shared sysfs interface as a loading facility:

  • Kobject uevent fallback mechanism
  • Custom fallback mechanism

First lets document the shared sysfs loading facility.

Firmware sysfs loading facility

In order to help device drivers upload firmware using a fallback mechanism the firmware infrastructure creates a sysfs interface to enable userspace to load and indicate when firmware is ready. The sysfs directory is created via fw_create_instance(). This call creates a new struct device named after the firmware requested, and establishes it in the device hierarchy by associating the device used to make the request as the device's parent. The sysfs directory's file attributes are defined and controlled through the new device's class (firmware_class) and group (fw_dev_attr_groups). This is actually where the original firmware_class module name came from, given that originally the only firmware loading mechanism available was the mechanism we now use as a fallback mechanism, which registers a struct class firmware_class. Because the attributes exposed are part of the module name, the module name firmware_class cannot be renamed in the future, to ensure backward compatibility with old userspace.

To load firmware using the sysfs interface we expose a loading indicator, and a file upload firmware into:

  • /sys/$DEVPATH/loading
  • /sys/$DEVPATH/data

To upload firmware you will echo 1 onto the loading file to indicate you are loading firmware. You then write the firmware into the data file, and you notify the kernel the firmware is ready by echo'ing 0 onto the loading file.

The firmware device used to help load firmware using sysfs is only created if direct firmware loading fails and if the fallback mechanism is enabled for your firmware request, this is set up with firmware_fallback_sysfs(). It is important to re-iterate that no device is created if a direct filesystem lookup succeeded.

Using:

echo 1 > /sys/$DEVPATH/loading

Will clean any previous partial load at once and make the firmware API return an error. When loading firmware the firmware_class grows a buffer for the firmware in PAGE_SIZE increments to hold the image as it comes in.

firmware_data_read() and firmware_loading_show() are just provided for the test_firmware driver for testing, they are not called in normal use or expected to be used regularly by userspace.

firmware_fallback_sysfs

int firmware_fallback_sysfs(struct firmware * fw, const char * name, struct device * device, enum fw_opt opt_flags, int ret)

use the fallback mechanism to find firmware

Parameters

struct firmware * fw
pointer to firmware image
const char * name
name of firmware file to look for
struct device * device
device for which firmware is being loaded
enum fw_opt opt_flags
options to control firmware loading behaviour
int ret
return value from direct lookup which triggered the fallback mechanism

Description

This function is called if direct lookup for the firmware failed, it enables a fallback mechanism through userspace by exposing a sysfs loading interface. Userspace is in charge of loading the firmware through the sysfs loading interface. This sysfs fallback mechanism may be disabled completely on a system by setting the proc sysctl value ignore_sysfs_fallback to true. If this is false we check if the internal API caller set the FW_OPT_NOFALLBACK_SYSFS flag, if so it would also disable the fallback mechanism. A system may want to enforce the sysfs fallback mechanism at all times, it can do this by setting ignore_sysfs_fallback to false and force_sysfs_fallback to true. Enabling force_sysfs_fallback is functionally equivalent to build a kernel with CONFIG_FW_LOADER_USER_HELPER_FALLBACK.

Firmware kobject uevent fallback mechanism

Since a device is created for the sysfs interface to help load firmware as a fallback mechanism userspace can be informed of the addition of the device by relying on kobject uevents. The addition of the device into the device hierarchy means the fallback mechanism for firmware loading has been initiated. For details of implementation refer to fw_load_sysfs_fallback(), in particular on the use of dev_set_uevent_suppress() and kobject_uevent().

The kernel's kobject uevent mechanism is implemented in lib/kobject_uevent.c, it issues uevents to userspace. As a supplement to kobject uevents Linux distributions could also enable CONFIG_UEVENT_HELPER_PATH, which makes use of core kernel's usermode helper (UMH) functionality to call out to a userspace helper for kobject uevents. In practice though no standard distribution has ever used the CONFIG_UEVENT_HELPER_PATH. If CONFIG_UEVENT_HELPER_PATH is enabled this binary would be called each time kobject_uevent_env() gets called in the kernel for each kobject uevent triggered.

Different implementations have been supported in userspace to take advantage of this fallback mechanism. When firmware loading was only possible using the sysfs mechanism the userspace component "hotplug" provided the functionality of monitoring for kobject events. Historically this was superseded be systemd's udev, however firmware loading support was removed from udev as of systemd commit be2ea723b1d0 ("udev: remove userspace firmware loading support") as of v217 on August, 2014. This means most Linux distributions today are not using or taking advantage of the firmware fallback mechanism provided by kobject uevents. This is specially exacerbated due to the fact that most distributions today disable CONFIG_FW_LOADER_USER_HELPER_FALLBACK.

Refer to do_firmware_uevent() for details of the kobject event variables setup. The variables currently passed to userspace with a "kobject add" event are:

  • FIRMWARE=firmware name
  • TIMEOUT=timeout value
  • ASYNC=whether or not the API request was asynchronous

By default DEVPATH is set by the internal kernel kobject infrastructure. Below is an example simple kobject uevent script:

# Both $DEVPATH and $FIRMWARE are already provided in the environment.
MY_FW_DIR=/lib/firmware/
echo 1 > /sys/$DEVPATH/loading
cat $MY_FW_DIR/$FIRMWARE > /sys/$DEVPATH/data
echo 0 > /sys/$DEVPATH/loading

Firmware custom fallback mechanism

Users of the request_firmware_nowait() call have yet another option available at their disposal: rely on the sysfs fallback mechanism but request that no kobject uevents be issued to userspace. The original logic behind this was that utilities other than udev might be required to lookup firmware in non-traditional paths -- paths outside of the listing documented in the section 'Direct filesystem lookup'. This option is not available to any of the other API calls as uevents are always forced for them.

Since uevents are only meaningful if the fallback mechanism is enabled in your kernel it would seem odd to enable uevents with kernels that do not have the fallback mechanism enabled in their kernels. Unfortunately we also rely on the uevent flag which can be disabled by request_firmware_nowait() to also setup the firmware cache for firmware requests. As documented above, the firmware cache is only set up if uevent is enabled for an API call. Although this can disable the firmware cache for request_firmware_nowait() calls, users of this API should not use it for the purposes of disabling the cache as that was not the original purpose of the flag. Not setting the uevent flag means you want to opt-in for the firmware fallback mechanism but you want to suppress kobject uevents, as you have a custom solution which will monitor for your device addition into the device hierarchy somehow and load firmware for you through a custom path.

Firmware fallback timeout

The firmware fallback mechanism has a timeout. If firmware is not loaded onto the sysfs interface by the timeout value an error is sent to the driver. By default the timeout is set to 60 seconds if uevents are desirable, otherwise MAX_JIFFY_OFFSET is used (max timeout possible). The logic behind using MAX_JIFFY_OFFSET for non-uevents is that a custom solution will have as much time as it needs to load firmware.

You can customize the firmware timeout by echo'ing your desired timeout into the following file:

  • /sys/class/firmware/timeout

If you echo 0 into it means MAX_JIFFY_OFFSET will be used. The data type for the timeout is an int.